Upon inspection of an Audemars Piguet Chronograph's movement, the importance of verifying that what looks right on the outside truly holds up on the inside is underscored.
This 18k white gold Audemars Piguet Code 11.59 Chronograph arrived at Bezel post-purchase for authentication. From the outside, that description held up. The watch was indeed authentic, and its case was clean, with no signs of previous wear. Moreover, its dial was free of marks, and nothing about the watch suggested anything conflicting with the seller’s description. It was only after the watch was handled more closely that something felt off.
Upon flipping it over and viewing its Cal. AP 4401 movement through the sapphire caseback, our authenticators quickly noticed that the rotor showed visible scuffing. Given the wear's far-from-subtle nature, they concluded it resulted from prior removal rather than incidental contact. It goes without saying that this detail mattered greatly, as a watch under warranty should not show evidence of internal mishandling.
Further inspection of the rest of the movement confirmed this suspicion. The wear pattern suggested the work hadn’t been done carefully and didn't resemble anything consistent with factory handling. Whatever had been done inside the case, it wasn’t recent, and it wasn’t professionally executed.
At that point, the listing no longer held. The watch may have looked good on the outside, but it did not meet Bezel’s strict condition parameters, nor was it what the buyer had agreed to purchase. As a result, the sale was rejected and the transaction canceled, at which point the buyer was assisted in sourcing another example that matched its marketed condition and was still eligible for service under the original manufacturer’s warranty.
This case is a reminder that buyer protector doesn't stop at determining whether or not a watch is authentic. Condition, originality, and handling history matter just as much, especially on modern watches still under manufacturer warranty. A watch can be fully authentic and still fail to meet the standards of what it's represented to be.
These are issues that only surface when a watch is examined as a complete mechanical system, not just from the outside. This story underscores why deeper inspection matters, and why it must be verified that what looks right on the outside truly holds up on the inside.
Bezel will continue to share insights like this so collectors can better understand the realities of the secondary market and move through it with clarity and confidence.
Bezel is the top-rated marketplace for buying and selling luxury watches. We give you access to tens of thousands of the most collectible watches from the world's top professional sellers and private collectors. Every watch sold goes through our industry-leading in-house authentication process, so you can buy, sell, and bid with confidence.
Download the Bezel app on the iOS App Store or start searching for your next watch today at getbezel.com.
Bezel is available to download on the App Store now. Please reach out to our concierge team if there is anything we can help you with!
©2024 Bezel Inc.
All rights reserved.